Cost Effectiveness of the Oregon Quitline "Free Patch Initiative"

Article Highlights

Study Title
Cost Effectiveness of the Oregon Quitline "Free Patch Initiative"
Study Authors
Jeffrey L. Fellows, Terry Bush, Tim McAfee, John Dickerson
Publication Date
2007
 

Overview

State Quitlines, such as Minnesota, Maine, and New York, have experimented and used free nicotine replacement therapy to increase reach and utilization of the quitline. Few have estimated the cost- effectiveness of the free NRT offerings. This study estimated the cost effectiveness of the Oregon Tobacco Quitline’s (ORQL) Free Patch Initiative. The Free Patch Initiative consisted of three combinations of telephone counseling and Nicotine Replacement Therapy (NRT) strategies for uninsured callers. The study was sponsored by the Oregon Tobacco Prevention and Evaluation Program (TPEP) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

Design

The authors utilized data from three sources: Oregon State, cost data from Free & Clear (the quitline provider) and participant data. Data consisted of: quitline utilization data, cost data (media & intervention costs), annual registration data and quit rates before and after the initiative.   Analyses were conducted on specific program costs and outcomes by conducting a best-case and worst-case scenario for each of the three counseling and NRT intervention strategies.  

Findings

Five major findings came out of this study:

  1. Free Patch Initiative program doubled the number of registered callers,
  2. Increased the number of ORQL quitters nearly five-fold,
  3. Reduced the cost per participant quit by $4,400.
  4. Generated 13,646 registration callers for nearly $2 million less than if TPEP had used paid media to prompt smokers to call.
  5. Produced over 900 more quits than if NRT had not been offered.

Conclusions

The Free Patch Initiative was a very cost effective method for increasing reach and quit rates in the Oregon uninsured population. The CEA method utilized compared what it would cost to reach the same number of Oregon residents via a paid promotional campaign. These findings are useful for state tobacco control program mangers and other decision makers, in particular during times of limited resources.


Table 1.0 Tobacco User Registration Calls to the Oregon Quitline Before and After the Free Patch Initiative

 



    6 months  
Year Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Total Avg Projected Annual
2004 1,346 507 349 416 284 312 3,214 536 6,428
2005 948 792 865 1,474 852 1,892 6,823 1,137 13,646
Difference (398) 285 516 1,058 568 1,580 3,609 602 7,218